• MINIKINO.ORG
  • FILM WEEK
  • INDONESIA RAJA
  • BEGADANG
Minikino
  • Home
  • SHORT FILMS
    Still Film of Eyes and Horns (2021) directed by Chaerin Im (dok: istimewa)

    Eyes And Horns: A Sensual Adventure In Perception

    Still Film of Apostrophe (2018) directed by Paopoom Chiwarak (dok: istimewa)

    Narrating our memory: Understanding The Past Through Short Film

    Still Film of Amelis (2016) directed by Dery Prananda (dok: istimewa)

    Fine Line Between Tragedy and Comedy

    Still film of Annah the Javanese (2020) directed by Fatimah Tobing Rony (dok: istimewa)

    Annah the Javanese, An Animated Ode to Untold Stories

    Still film of The Sound of the Time (2021) directed by Jeissy Trompiz (dok: istimewa)

    Kuasa, Suara, dan Nestapa

    Still Film of Chicken Awaken (Nol Derajat Film) (dok: istimewa)

    Begadang boleh saja, asal ada batasnya

    Still Film of Semua Karena Cinta (2021) directed by Beni Arona (dok: istimewa)

    Ruang dan Prasangka

    Still Film of While My Goatee Gently Bleats (2021) directed by Pahurak Kong (dok: istimewa)

    While My Goatee Gently Bleats (2021): Hukuman Mati Tidak Pernah Masuk Akal

    Still Film of Candlelight (2022) directed by Polen LY (dok: istimewa)

    Candlelight (2022): Lilin dan Hal yang Tidak Habis dari Dirinya

  • NOTES
  • INTERVIEWS
  • INTERNATIONAL
  • OPINION
  • CONTACT
No Result
View All Result
Minikino Articles
  • Home
  • SHORT FILMS
    Still Film of Eyes and Horns (2021) directed by Chaerin Im (dok: istimewa)

    Eyes And Horns: A Sensual Adventure In Perception

    Still Film of Apostrophe (2018) directed by Paopoom Chiwarak (dok: istimewa)

    Narrating our memory: Understanding The Past Through Short Film

    Still Film of Amelis (2016) directed by Dery Prananda (dok: istimewa)

    Fine Line Between Tragedy and Comedy

    Still film of Annah the Javanese (2020) directed by Fatimah Tobing Rony (dok: istimewa)

    Annah the Javanese, An Animated Ode to Untold Stories

    Still film of The Sound of the Time (2021) directed by Jeissy Trompiz (dok: istimewa)

    Kuasa, Suara, dan Nestapa

    Still Film of Chicken Awaken (Nol Derajat Film) (dok: istimewa)

    Begadang boleh saja, asal ada batasnya

    Still Film of Semua Karena Cinta (2021) directed by Beni Arona (dok: istimewa)

    Ruang dan Prasangka

    Still Film of While My Goatee Gently Bleats (2021) directed by Pahurak Kong (dok: istimewa)

    While My Goatee Gently Bleats (2021): Hukuman Mati Tidak Pernah Masuk Akal

    Still Film of Candlelight (2022) directed by Polen LY (dok: istimewa)

    Candlelight (2022): Lilin dan Hal yang Tidak Habis dari Dirinya

  • NOTES
  • INTERVIEWS
  • INTERNATIONAL
  • OPINION
  • CONTACT
No Result
View All Result
Minikino
No Result
View All Result
Home SHORT FILMS

A Reflection on Racist Structures in Germany’s Public Authorities

Mona & Parviz (2021) Film Review

Joelle Bavoux by Joelle Bavoux
August 29, 2022
in SHORT FILMS
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Still film of Mona & Parviz (2021) directed by Kevin Biele

Still film of Mona & Parviz (2021) directed by Kevin Biele

A couple of months ago, I watched a theater play on the conditions set by the office of foreign affairs that refugee children must face, when applying for the family reunification process in Germany. I left the play with a mixed feeling of discomfort and anger. These feelings came back when I watched Mona & Parviz. Being part of this year’s Minikino Youth Jury Award, the German short film represents a relevant depiction of the degrading processes behind the German foreigner office. Taking a clear stance, Mona & Parviz confronted me with a reality that provokes appalling concerns about the “welcomeness” of my home country.

One morning, two unknown people ring Mona’s and Parviz doorbell: They introduce themselves as employees of the foreign affairs office and have come to verify the marriage situation between Mona and Parviz. Parviz is from Iran and depends on his marriage to obtain a residence permit. But since he is currently not home, Mona must face the probing investigation of the employees alone. When Parviz finally arrives, he seems intimidated by their presence and questions. In the end, Parviz announces to them the news about Mona’s pregnancy.  

Until the end of the film, the viewer is left in the dark about whether their marriage is sincere or pretended. There are several reasons that let us take the distrustful attitude of the authority. For example, Mona does not wear her wedding ring, and the responses of the two show inconsistencies, making us feel like the two just got “caught”. However, it also reinforces the empathy that we feel towards the couple. 

Throughout the narrative, the film reflects the issue of racism on multiple levels. The main premise represents the structural racism that the two must face, personified in the appearance of the two employees that arouse the impression to resent some sort of satisfaction by the thought of catching the two. Throughout the film, the intimacy of their interrogations knows no borders, and their viewing of the flat is more than intruding. No wonder that Mona asks at some point: “What else do you want to see? Our Sextape?”. This intrusion is also found in the camera work of the film. Using a handheld camera throughout the process, we follow the protagonists with an obtrusive closeness through the flat, taking part in all intimacies of their marriage.

In addition, while inspecting the flat, one of the employees asks Mona in an over-friendly friendly tone: “Did you meet here or in your home country?”. In a moment of disbelief, Mona answers: “I was born here”. But he still doesn’t seem to accept her answer.

We would think that people nowadays are not that ignorant to automatically assume that someone is not German due to a darker skin or a foreign name. Or that in a supposedly open country, people don’t have to explain themselves due to their appearances. Or that in general, the color of your skin doesn’t play a part anymore. But Mona & Parviz prove differently.

In doing so, the film reflects the reality of people from the Middle-East that must confront structural and everyday racism. It further depicts the challenging and repetitive processes behind the residence approval, that, at the end, offer no certain outcome for the applicants. And it shows the endurance and humiliation that people must go through, as they depend on the “good-naturedness” of the employees responsible for foreign affairs.

This topic is certainly not addressed for the first time in this film. But as it shows, there seems to be no visible change. During the past years, we could see an alarming growing anti- refugee, asylum-seekers, or migrant rhetoric and violence in Germany. This especially concerns people coming or descending from Middle Eastern or African countries. It shows the strong urgency of films like Mona & Parviz that address issues of racism. 

At the end of the film, we can see the pressure building up on Parviz. To convince the two employees, he tells them about the pregnancy of his wife, making them eventually leave the apartment. Handing Mona over a pregnancy test, which purchase explains his prior absence, she locks herself up in the toilet. Whether she is ultimately pregnant or not remains open. At least, we have the certainty that the two are not faking their relationship. But in the end, does that really matter?

Tags: EnglishFestival WritersGermanyImmigrantMona & Parvizshort film
ShareTweetPin
Previous Post

Why Do We Do What We Do?

Next Post

“The Blanket” of ASEAN Migrants Irony

Joelle Bavoux

Joelle Bavoux

Joelle is a film and audiovisual media student at the University of Groningen that likes nostalgic, critical, and absurd films. Having a special interest in Southeast Asian film culture, Joelle is currently writing her thesis on Indonesian horror films.

Related Posts

Still Film of Eyes and Horns (2021) directed by Chaerin Im (dok: istimewa)

Eyes And Horns: A Sensual Adventure In Perception

October 18, 2022
Still Film of Apostrophe (2018) directed by Paopoom Chiwarak (dok: istimewa)

Narrating our memory: Understanding The Past Through Short Film

October 2, 2022
Still Film of Amelis (2016) directed by Dery Prananda (dok: istimewa)

Fine Line Between Tragedy and Comedy

October 1, 2022
Still film of Annah the Javanese (2020) directed by Fatimah Tobing Rony (dok: istimewa)

Annah the Javanese, An Animated Ode to Untold Stories

September 22, 2022
Still film of The Sound of the Time (2021) directed by Jeissy Trompiz (dok: istimewa)

Kuasa, Suara, dan Nestapa

September 11, 2022
Still Film of Chicken Awaken (Nol Derajat Film) (dok: istimewa)

Begadang boleh saja, asal ada batasnya

September 8, 2022

Discussion about this post

Kirim Tulisan

Siapapun boleh ikutan meramaikan halaman artikel di minikino.org.

Silahkan kirim artikel anda ke info@minikino.org. Isinya bebas, mau berbagi, curhat, kritik, saran, asalkan masih dalam lingkup kegiatan-kegiatan yang dilakukan Minikino, film pendek dan budaya sinema, baik khusus atau secara umum. Agar halaman ini bisa menjadi catatan bersama untuk kerja yang lebih baik lagi ke depan.

Minikino Head Loop Mask Minikino Head Loop Mask Minikino Head Loop Mask
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Gambar dihasilkan melalui DALL-E 2

Artificial Intelligence: Cerdas Bukan Artinya Kreatif

January 5, 2023
Short Film Distribution Talks & Book Seminar "I (dok: Bintang/Minikino)Made A Short Film Now WTF Do I Do With It?"  (dok: Bintang/Minikino)

Membahas Distribusi dan Festival Film Pendek Bersama Clarissa Jacobson

January 13, 2023
Webinar dari Objectifs "How to Make The Most Of Film Festivals". -  Dok: Objectifs

Formula Jitu Agar Film Pendekmu Masuk ke Banyak Festival Film!

August 13, 2021

Sejarah (Istilah) Film Indie

May 8, 2017
Still Film of A Ride to Nowhere (2022) directed by Khozy Rizal (dok: istimewa)

A Ride To Nowhere (2022): Perempuan dalam Dominasi Maskulinitas Industri Kerja

August 30, 2022
Short Film Distribution Talks & Book Seminar "I (dok: Bintang/Minikino)Made A Short Film Now WTF Do I Do With It?"  (dok: Bintang/Minikino)

Membahas Distribusi dan Festival Film Pendek Bersama Clarissa Jacobson

January 13, 2023
Gambar dihasilkan melalui DALL-E 2

Artificial Intelligence: Cerdas Bukan Artinya Kreatif

January 5, 2023
Post Festival Roadshow Jakarta (dok: Erde/Minikino)

Suasana MFW8 di Jakarta

December 3, 2022
Still Film of Sawankhalai (2017) directed by Abhichon Rattanabhayon (dok: istimewa)

When the Fly on the Wall Got Noticed

November 28, 2022
POST FESTIVAL ROADSHOW 2022: ACEH

Film Pendek Dan Serba-Serbi Dari Serambi Makkah

November 17, 2022

ABOUT US

Minikino is an Indonesia’s short film festival organization with an international networking. We works throughout the year, arranging and organizing various forms of short film festivals and its supporting activities with their own sub-focus.

Follow us

RECENT NEWS

  • Membahas Distribusi dan Festival Film Pendek Bersama Clarissa Jacobson
  • Artificial Intelligence: Cerdas Bukan Artinya Kreatif
  • Suasana MFW8 di Jakarta
  • When the Fly on the Wall Got Noticed

CATEGORIES

  • Articles
  • INTERVIEWS
  • NOTES
  • OPINION
  • PODCAST
  • SHORT FILMS
  • VIDEO

Minikino Film Week 8

  • MINIKINO.ORG
  • FILM WEEK
  • INDONESIA RAJA
  • BEGADANG

© 2021 Minikino | Yayasan Kino Media

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • SHORT FILMS
  • NOTES
  • INTERVIEWS
  • INTERNATIONAL
  • OPINION
  • CONTACT

© 2021 Minikino | Yayasan Kino Media

-
00:00
00:00

Queue

Update Required Flash plugin
-
00:00
00:00